Abstract：The study analyzed about 37,000 forex candles, identifying over 200 Bearish Engulfings (BEs), suggesting BEs serve better as market peaking signals rather than reversal ones. While the average post-BE trend showed a slight downward bias, about 2/3 stayed below the peak, indicating potential predictive power.
The Bearish Engulfing (BE) is a prominent candlestick formation that can be detected across multiple financial trading instruments. It needs nothing more than an opening, high, low, and closing price for identification. As suggested by the name, technical traders commonly use this as an indicator that a rising market may be on the cusp of a reversal. However, one must remember that previous performance doesn't necessarily predict future outcomes.
The objective of this educational article is not to delve into the nuances of Bearish Engulfing, but to evaluate their effectiveness using only price information. This data will be drawn from the foreign exchange market (forex). At the end of this discussion, we will recap the key insights and mention some of the limitations of this research. Let's lay some ground rules first.
Around 37,000 candles across EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY, AUD/USD, and USD/CAD were analyzed using daily data from TradingView since 1995. One of the reasons why the forex market was selected is due to its unmatched liquidity, particularly among the major pairs, which results in more streamlined price action compared to markets like stocks and cryptocurrencies.
The identification of Bearish Engulfing was based on a pre-set of rules I coded, scanning each candle to verify its validity. For this study, I focused on a short-term horizon, meaning 20 days before and after an engulfing.
Let's take a look at some of the most critical rules used in Bearish Engulfing detection:
Bearish Engulfing Detection Criteria:
1. The Bearish Engulfing body must meet a minimum size requirement, it can't be excessively small.
2. The body of the preceding candle (the pre-candle) can't be too small in comparison to the BE body.
3. The BE must close below the pre-candle open, rather than the pre-candle low.
4. Before the BE, there must be signs of an uptrend (no flat price action or downtrends).
5. The pre-candle close must also be a 20-day high close, allowing for a slight margin of error.
Limitations and subjectivity related to these rules will be addressed later. For now, let's review an example of a detected EUR/USD Bearish Engulfing from March 13th, 2005. It shows a clear uptrend before the BE and a 20-day high close of the pre-candle. After the BE, the price declined as expected.
The code identified slightly more than 200 Bearish Engulfings out of nearly 37,000 candles. Naturally, not all of them were as clear-cut as the one demonstrated.
The chart below presents each Bearish Engulfing trend 20 days before and after its occurrence. To ensure consistent scaling, each BE (close) was indexed to 100 as a reference point.
In the phase leading up to the BE, it's visible that the trends rose steadily and predictably. However, the day preceding the BE always peaked. This leads to the dip into the BE, marking the close below the pre-candle.
Post the Bearish Engulfing, trends persist for 20 days, widening into a conical or triangular shape as time passes. The right side of the graph shows greater price dispersion (variance) than the left, characterized by numerous peaks and troughs. At first sight, this might suggest randomness, casting doubt on the reliability of Bearish Engulfings as regular reversal signals. However, a closer examination is required.
The next chart helps in understanding the average Bearish Engulfing trend. It confirms that the code reliably captured the uptrend preceding the BE. As with the earlier chart, you can see the peak just before the BE, followed by a dip to 100, symbolizing the descent into the engulfing. Post engulfing, prices continued to fall, finishing at an average of -0.28% 20 days after the BE. While this indicates a mild downward bias in the post-BE trend, it's not the crucial takeaway from this analysis.
The final chart overlays the average Bearish Engulfing series with the percentage of trends that closed below the pre-candle for each day. For instance: after 5 days, 71% of trends stayed below the pre-candle close. After 10 days, this figure reduced to 66%, then rose to 68% on the 15th day and finally ended at 65% on the 20th day. In other words, on average, about two-thirds (2/3) of trends remained below the peak after one month.
An interesting observation is that the ending price observations after 20 days formed a statistically significant normal distribution. This means we can use a Cumulative Distribution Function (CDF) to calculate the probability of a series in this sample finishing below the peak. Consistent with the results mentioned earlier, this is approximately 65%.
After analyzing nearly 37,000 candles between EUR/USD, GBP/USD, USD/JPY, AUD/USD, and USD/CAD, and identifying over 200 Bearish Engulfings, it appears that this candlestick pattern serves better as a peaking signal than a reversal one. While the average trend finished almost -0.3% after 20 days, 2/3 of them stayed below the peak. This implies that if we can spot valid Bearish Engulfings in this market, it might be worth monitoring. Now, let's discuss some limitations of this study.
While Bearish Engulfings can be found universally across markets, understand that this study focused on a specific subset of the forex market. Hence, the results may be most relevant to the pairs studied. Also, this research is based on a sample of just over 200 Bearish Engulfings. A larger sample might be needed to bolster the validity of this study (or perhaps contradict it).
Despite efforts to maintain objectivity, technical analysis inherently involves a degree of subjectivity. While there's broad agreement on the characteristics of a Bearish Engulfing, the context in which they form is more variable. In this sample, I considered if the BE closed below the pre-candle open rather than the pre-candle low, which may be debated by some.
The timeframe is another crucial aspect. This study was conducted on daily data, but other time horizons could theoretically be analyzed. This includes the duration you measure before and after the engulfing. This study focused on short-term price action, but broader trends could also be analyzed, such as 40 days before and after the Bearish Engulfing.
The study provides insights into the nature of Bearish Engulfing patterns within the forex market and their potential predictive power. Our findings suggest that while the average trend after a BE may show a slight downward bias, the primary value of BE patterns might lie in their capacity to signal market peaks rather than trend reversals. This makes them a potentially valuable tool for traders in interpreting market conditions and managing risk.
However, this study also highlights the limitations and potential areas of subjective interpretation inherent in technical analysis. It emphasizes the need for a comprehensive and diversified approach to market analysis, incorporating multiple timeframes, indicators, and types of data. Ultimately, successful trading strategies must adapt to the ever-changing dynamics of the forex market, and no single pattern or indicator can provide a foolproof guide to future price movements. Therefore, traders should use BE patterns as part of a broader, balanced analytical toolkit.
Today is FOMC day, and it's going to be busy. New Zealand will present Q2 current account data and Japan will present August trade data during the Asian session. The Australian Westpac Leading Index will also be made public. The People's Bank of China (PBoC) interest rate decision will be the main topic of discussion. The UK will present August inflation statistics later today, and Germany will present wholesale inflation data. The Federal Reserve will make its monetary policy announcement during the American session.
After Reuters reported, citing sources, that Country Garden, the largest private property developer in China, from its creditors to postpone the repayment of six onshore notes by three years, the markets experienced. The small increases in Asian indices are being aided by the tech companies on Wall Street.
Explore the alarming case of Sophie Capital Financial Trading Pty Ltd, an unregulated online trading broker that has vanished, leaving clients unable to access their funds, shedding light on the risks associated with unregulated brokers in the financial industry.
DAX, a Philippine cryptocurrency exchange, will delist Binance USD (BUSD) from its platform following Binance’s decision to withdraw support for the stablecoin. PDAX users must convert or transfer their BUSD assets before October 27, 2023, or they will be automatically converted to PHP.